WEALTH-TAX OFFICER v. M.K. MONGA
[Citation -1987-LL-0112-4]
Citation | 1987-LL-0112-4 |
---|---|
Appellant Name | WEALTH-TAX OFFICER |
Respondent Name | M.K. MONGA |
Court | ITAT |
Relevant Act | Wealth-tax |
Date of Order | 12/01/1987 |
Assessment Year | 1979-80 |
Judgment | View Judgment |
Keyword Tags | wealth-tax assessment • registered sale deed • immovable property • market value • legal owner • legal title • net wealth |
Bot Summary: | Authorised counsel of the assessee that if the property in question did not belong to the assessee, no part of its value could be included in the net wealth and that in any case when the WTO had treated the property as belonging to the assessee and included in his net wealth the value thereof, the deduction under s. 5(1) became allowable and that the AAC was justified in granting that deduction. The possession of the properties had been handed over to the purchasers. The question arose as to whether the property still belonged to the Nizam. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that even where an agreement or contract to sell a property had been executed and the purchaser had been put in possession and where the purchaser had every right to enforce specific performance and execution of the sale deed in the event of the vendor being not willing to do so, the puachaser could not be treated as the legal owner and the vendor still continued to be vested with the legal title and that the property would still belong to the vendor in the eyes of law. In view of this pronouncement the assessee- respondent, who was still to get the property registered in its name by execution of a formal registered sale deed, could not be considered to be the person to whom the property belonged. The interest of the assessee-respondent in the property in question would have to be valued not on basis that it was an immovable property belonging to it, but on the basis that it had rights in the property other than those of legal ownership. In the situation that now prevails in view of the latest pronouncement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court 28 TAXMAN 641 we deem it is proper and in the interests of justice that the matter is restored to file of the WTO in order that the wealth-tax assessment in respect of the property in question in redone in accordance with the law as laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. |