DIGCHEM INDUSTRIES v. INCOME TAX OFFICER
[Citation -1986-LL-1118-1]
Citation | 1986-LL-1118-1 |
---|---|
Appellant Name | DIGCHEM INDUSTRIES |
Respondent Name | INCOME TAX OFFICER |
Court | ITAT |
Relevant Act | Income-tax |
Date of Order | 18/11/1986 |
Assessment Year | 1983-84 |
Judgment | View Judgment |
Keyword Tags | quantum of deduction • gross total income |
Bot Summary: | In this appeal by the assessee the issue involved is about the deduction to be allowed under s. 80-I as well as the quantum of deduction that is permissible under the Act. The plea of the assessee was that s. 80-I deduction follows s. 80 HH deduction under Chapter 6A and both these sections emphasised on deduction to be calculated at 20 per cent of the profits and gains of the undertaking. The Department is restricting the deduction under s. 80-I at 20 per cent of the income arrived at after deduction of the amount of relief under s. 80-HH. The assessee prayed that the order of the CIT(A) is erroneous on this point of view and that he is entitled to deduction under s. 80-I at 20 per cent on the profits and gains. The argument of the Departmental Representative was that the provisions contained in s. 80HH(9) goes to support the view of the Department that the deduction in respect s. 80-I shall be limited to the net income after deduction already allowed under s. 80HH. We have given very careful consideration to the arguments of the parties. A t the outset we must observe that s. 80HH(1) and s. 80-I(1) lay emphasis on amount to be allowed as a deduction in computing the total income of the assessee from such profits and gains of the undertaking of amount equal to 20 per cent thereof. The sections do not anywhere mention that the deduction to be allowed is 20 per cent of the income computed in accordance with the provisions of the act after the relief contained upto Chapter 6A. The s. 80HH(9) only provides that when a concern is entitled to deduction under s. 80HH, s. 80-I and or s. 80J then the first of the deduction that would have to be allowed is a deduction under s. 80HH. This only is a clarification in case of such successive reliefs that the relief in respect of earlier section would have to be allowed in full. Therefore the assessee is entitled to relief under s. 80-I to the tune of 20 per cent of the profits as per its profits loss account without taking into account the depreciation and excluding the provision for income-tax as well as the investment allowance. |