HINDUSTAN ENGG., CO. v. INCOME TAX OFFICER
[Citation -1986-LL-1113-2]
Citation | 1986-LL-1113-2 |
---|---|
Appellant Name | HINDUSTAN ENGG., CO. |
Respondent Name | INCOME TAX OFFICER |
Court | ITAT |
Relevant Act | Income-tax |
Date of Order | 13/11/1986 |
Assessment Year | 1980-81, 1981-82 |
Judgment | View Judgment |
Keyword Tags | deduction of tax at source • disallowance of interest • advance tax instalment • income from business • registered firm • payment of tax • contract work • interest paid • co-operative |
Bot Summary: | These appeals are directed against the disallowance of interest computing the income of the assessee and the denial of interest under s. 214 of the IT Act, 1961. The assessee is a registered firm which had obtained a contract for the construction of building for the MES. The assessee framed out the contract and the income consisted only of the commission received from the sub-contract. The claim of the assessee to deduct the interest paid on the borrowed money w a s rejected by the authorities below on the ground that the income of the assessee was not a business income and the amount borrowed had not been utilised for the purposes of business. The assessee has disputed both the points by claiming that the income even from framing out the contract is income from business as held in CIT vs. S.K. Sahana Sons Ltd. 102 ITR 437 and that the amount was actually advanced only for the purposes of the contract and it was for the purposes of the business. The assessee has also pointed out that the advance tax instalment payable is itself calculated under the Act only after taking into account the tax deducted, at source and if a refund materialises because of excess payment of tax in whatever form, interest is to be given under s. 214 since the Govt, had the benefit of the amount within the accounting year. Even though the Allahabad High Court is in favour of the assessee, we find all the provisions of the Act land themselves to a different interpretation favouring the assessee inasmuch as the interest is payable on the tax refunded which cannot be identified as either the excess of advance tax paid or the excess of tax deducted at source. To accept the claim of the assessee and direct the ITO to grant interest under s. 214 in respect of the amount of tax refunded to the assessee. |